Massmart and the economic development department are proud to announce that the massmart group has procured r1billion worth of products from the small, local manufacturers on the supplier development programme. Walmart stores inc v massmart holdings ltd 73lmdec10. The walmartmassmart merger provides a suitable case study in which to assess the. May 16, 2011 as the south african competition tribunal wound down hearings on the proposed merger of walmart and massmart on monday, the countrys competition commission changed its recommendation on the deal. Expert analysis on impact of walmartmassmart merger. The walmart massmart merger was initially approved by the competition commission at the end of may with several conditions attached. This was considered a seminal case regarding public interest issues. Here at, we are committed to protecting your privacy. Walmart stores will now trade in south africa, with the competition tribunal having approved its merger with massmart subject to conditions, said the tribunal.
Massmart and walmart agree to negotiate exclusively. We comment on the specific remedies imposed by the tribunal in this case. The government departments and unions had argued that the tribunal should impose targets for using local suppliers on walmart. Walmart, massmart merger approved in south africa wsj. The festive season is continuing with a bang for a familyowned company in kwazulunatal, glenart, which this week won the chance to export its christmas crackers to walmart in the minister lauds massmart supplier programme. Walmart gets first foothold in africa business the guardian. Jun 01, 2011 walmart stores will now trade in south africa, with the competition tribunal having approved its merger with massmart subject to conditions, said the tribunal. Walmart massmart acquisition walmarts acquisition of massmart. The purpose of the report is to respond to allegations made by various complainants about the impact of the proposed acquisition by walmart of a 51% stake in massmart. Springer nature is making coronavirus research free.
Walmart massmart submission mr grant pattison, chief executive officer, massmart, said that mergers in south africa were highly regulated, and various regulatory authorities had jurisdiction. The companies had to comply not only with the competition act, but also the companies act and there was a high level of involvement by stakeholders. Walmart had to set up a r100m supplier development fund to help. The local firm, massmart, is the fourth largest retailer in. The competition commission said the merger should only go through if walmart hires back 503 workers fired by massmart as it prepared for walmart.
Massmart is the secondlargest distributor of consumer goods in africa, the leading retailer of general merchandise, liquor and home improvement equipment and supplies, and the leading wholesaler of basic foods. In a media briefing in pretoria this morning, the ministers of economic development ebrahim patel, trade and. The committee continued with the second day of hearings into the walmart massmart merger. Toward the end of 2012, massmart issued a request for a proposal to researchers at the university of cape town graduate school of business. Namibian authorities approve massmartwalmart merger. The aims and origins of the corporation walmart is the worlds biggest retailer, largest private employer and makes sales in excess of three billion dollars each week. The company cannot retrench staff in the next two years due to operational requirements. Massmartwalmart were yesterday advised by the ministry of trade and industry in namibia that the merger has been approved in namibia subject to the following three conditions.
Economic development minister ebrahim patel has applauded retailer massmart s programme to procure products from. Walmart, and edward nathan sonnenbergs, acting on behalf of massmart holdings ltd. On 18 january 2011, massmart shareholders voted in favour of walmarts offer of r148 per share. A south african appeals court judge upheld a decision made by the countrys competition authorities to approve walmarts acquisition of a majority stake in south african retailer massmart, but.
South africa approves walmart, massmart merger with. Massmart partners with walmarts global sourcing team to help local suppliers export to walmart markets. South africas competition appeal court has dismissed an application by the governments trade and agriculture ministries to effectively delay approval of a proposed merger between us retail giant walmart and south african retail group massmart judge dennis davis said a lack of evidence that the merger would adversely affect small and mediumsized businesses meant that the court could not. The group comprises nine wholesale and retail chains, and one buying group, operating in 12 countries in subsaharan africa as massdiscounters, masswarehouse, massbuild and masscash stores. This is because while previous merger assessments have been decided on public interest grounds, these concerns were acknowledged, and recommendations put forward, by the commission. The team canvas is business model canvas for teamwork. Walmart stores inc v massmart holdings ltd 73lmdec10 2011. Dna is a specialist economics and development consultancy that brings together technical, policy and strategy skills to provide economic solutions to public and private sector clients across southern africa. Supply chain african country shopping mall capital expenditure merge entity. Walmart will be entering south africa through the acquisition strategy, primarily, because it did not want to set up a greenfields operation.
Why massmart and moresport may not merge june 2006 on 10 april 2006 the competition tribunal prohibited the merger between massmart holdings ltd and moresport ltd, concluding that the merger is likely to lead to a substantial prevention or lessening of competition in the national markets for the general retailing of sports and outdoor equipment. Walmart is best suited for the research as it is the largest company in the world and retail involves significant operations in a. Operating profit before walmart costs and forex up by 6. Msm is a south african firm that owns local brands such as game, makro, builders warehouse and cbw. Massmart is the secondlargest distributor of consumer goods in africa, the leading retailer of general merchandise, liquor and home improvement equipment and. This was considered a seminal case regarding public interest issues related to mergers and acquisitions in south africa.
The emphasis is on three pieces of multilateral legislation. A merger of the size of the proposed walmart massmart transaction, and with the size and leverage of the parties which are involved, could, if not properly regulated, go some way towards. Massmart operates more than 400 retail units in south africa and 12 other subsaharan countries. At the outset, the chairperson explained that the committee had postponed these hearings for some time, pending a decision by the competition authorities, and was aware that a notice of appeal had been issued, but the committee still had to report to parliament on questions of employment. Feb 22, 2012 this working paper aims to answer this question against the backdrop of the walmart massmart merger approval process and the facts applicable in the case.
Entry shall mean entry by means of a merger, acquisition or takeover. In 2011, walmart acquired a majority stake in massmart holdings limited, also known as the group. Finally, section 5 examines how the transaction might affect suppliers margins and the prices at which they sell to massmart, given potential changes in bargaining power and the established. Walmart massmart deal blogs, comments and archive news on. Massmart further donated generators and equipment to support the south african national department of healths efforts in responding to the ebola outbreak in west africa. The objective of the research proposal was to assess the impact of the massmart walmart merger on factors such as consumer pricing, job creation, emerging farmer development and local manufacturing. Walmart massmart deal latest breaking news, pictures, videos, and special reports from the economic times. Merge pdf files combine pdfs in the order you want with the easiest pdf merger available. A merger of the size of the proposed walmartmassmart transaction, and with the size and leverage of the parties which are involved, could, if not properly regulated, go some way towards.
South african shareholders and regulatory authorities approve massmart and walmart merger massmart and walmart announce that transaction has been finalised massmart thuthukani trust pays r396 million pretax to employee shareholders. The departments had opposed the merger, arguing it would lead to the loss of jobs as well as put suppliers out of work. Merger remedies and the walmartmassmart case econex. Walmart stores inc v massmart holdings ltd 73lmdec10 2011 zact 41 29 june 2011. The walmart massmart merger provides a suitable case study in which to assess the potential interaction between competition law and industrial policy. Massmart has grown to over 28,000 associates in 365 stores. The approval comes with conditions and rules both proposed by walmart and massmart. At the outset, the chairperson explained that the committee had postponed these hearings for some time, pending a decision by the competition authorities, and was aware that a notice of appeal had been issued, but the committee still had to report to parliament on questions of. The committee continued with the third day of hearings into the walmart massmart merger. Prior to the merger, walmart had a very limited interest in the south african market. Ministers challenge walmartmassmart merger skills portal. Wmt announced today that it has offered to acquire 51% of the shares of massmart holdings limited jse. Walmart is known for bringing about lower prices and as such, economists feel that this merger will be good for competition and giving south african consumers additional choices along with competitive low prices. May 31, 2011 retail giant walmart in november made a r16.
It is the secondlargest distributor of consumer goods in africa, the largest retailer of general merchandise, liquor and home improvement equipment and wholesaler of basic foods. At the end of may, the tribunal decided to allow the us retail giant to merge with massmart with conditions, resulting in walmart acquiring 51% of the south african retailer. You can download this page as a pdf using your browsers print functionality. Oct 10, 2011 the walmart massmart merger was initially approved by the competition commission at the end of may with several conditions attached. Walmart stores inc v massmart holdings ltd 73lmdec10 2011 zact 28 31 may 2011 download original files. As you are aware, the competition tribunal the tribunal approved the proposed merger with conditions on 31 may 2011 and provided its reasons for doing so on 29 june 2011. It is the secondlargest distributor of consumer goods in africa, the largest retailer of general merchandise, liquor and home.
Massmart is a south africanbased globally competitive regional management group, invested in a portfolio of differentiated, complementary, focused wholesale and retail formats. The walmart massmart matter was now beyond the reach of the cc in the sense that the implementation of the merger conditions was being done in terms of a court ruling. Competition commission update on walmartmassmart merger. Walmart confirms intention to make a firm offer to acquire a. Push for conditions on walmart buy of massmart the united. Under the terms of the deal, walmart bought a 51% stake in. Ministers say walmartmassmart merger poses a risk the. Ministers say walmartmassmart merger poses a risk the mail. In september 2010 walmart put in an offer to buy the massmart group. The presentation would also touch on the market enquiry being done on health issues, and the construction fasttrack project, which had been reported in the media. The company indicated that the merger was to be used as a gateway and springboard into africa.
Select multiple pdf files and merge them in seconds. Public interest test and merger control in south africa. South africa resists march of walmart business the guardian. She further requested anyone involved in the walmart massmart. Massmart will continue to trade on the jse limited to provide massmart shareholders with the ability to participate in the growth.
The walmart merger implications for competition law in developing. Genesis was appointed to provide expert analysis on walmarts proposed acquisition of massmart by affected trade unions, which were later joined by the department of economic development. The recently approved acquisition of a 51% stake in massmart by walmart has brought about a lot of speculation as to whether this deal will mainly positively impact south africas gdp or not. When it does, walmart wants to be ready to seize the day. Walmarts acquisition of massmart the deal initial offer. Walmart acquired a majority stake in massmart holdings ltd. These conditions are all behavioural remedies and include the following. Walmartmassmart deal approved with conditions the mail. South africa resists march of walmart business the. May 31, 2011 walmart gets first foothold in africa this article is more than 8 years old walmart has been approved to buy south africas massmart despite fierce union opposition, clearing the way for it to. Massmart board withdraws or adversely modifies its recommendation a higher offer is made and succeeds for the acquisition of 35% of massmart ordinary shares rand denominated mutual exclusivity until the offer becomes wholly unconditional.
Aug 30, 2017 johannesburg when american multinational retail company walmart made an offer to buy a 51% stake in massmart, which owns game, builders, dionwired, makro and jumbo among others, the retail group saw the growth opportunities such an acquisition would present. Walmart gets first foothold in africa this article is more than 8 years old walmart has been approved to buy south africas massmart despite fierce union opposition, clearing the way for it. Walmart stores inc v massmart holdings ltd 73lmdec10 2011 zact 42 29 june 2011. In 2011 walmart announced its merger with south africas retailer massmart and was eventually approved by the countrys competition tribunal in order for the deal to go through. Walmart gets first foothold in africa business the. Investment approval of the walmart massmart merger is conditional on complyin with the conditions that are imposed by the competition authorities. However, competitors in the market felt differently and challenged the acquisition. This week, walmart stores wmt, fortune 500 announced a cash offer for a majority stake in the south african retail company massmart holdings, ltd. Massmart is of the view that given walmarts collective skills and capabilities, they will enable the merged entity to implement its pre merger expansion plans with more confidence and on an expedited basis, as the merged entity will be able to draw on skills, systems and processes already developed, tried and tested by walmart. Massmart operates more than 400 stores in south africa and 12 other subsaharan countries. The tactic of only acquiring only a 51% share in massmart, has afforded walmart the opportunity to assume control, whilst avoiding even. Walmarts sales are equivalent in size to the worlds 23rd largest economy, norway, and exceeds the gdp of sa shevel, the sunday times, 22 may 2011a. The competition tribunal has today approved the merger between walmart stores inc. The research will be done on how stakeholders were managed by walmart during its recent entry into south africa.
660 1567 1082 533 1552 1093 518 370 1034 371 1537 1169 643 6 1094 774 1268 1069 68 1004 572 1 784 536 1019 1283 682 611 693 112 223 1318 459 638 785 903 914 610 1337 161 113 292